Insurance · ~4 min read · updated Nov 16, 2026 (Asia/Shanghai)

10 Common Insurance Myths That Cost People Money

Flat illustration of a magnifying glass over an insurance policy document with myth and fact labels in blue tones

Most expensive insurance mistakes do not come from buying the wrong company. They come from believing something about a policy that was never true in the first place. Here are ten of the most common myths, each paired with the fact that matters.

Home insurance myths that leave houses underinsured

Myth 1: My homeowners policy covers flood damage. Standard homeowners policies typically exclude damage from rising water, storm surges, groundwater, and runoff. A burst pipe is usually covered as a sudden accident; water rising from a river or storm surge is not. Buy flood coverage separately, through the National Flood Insurance Program or a private flood insurer.

Fact: Flood risk is not limited to high-risk zones. Only about 4% of single-family homes in the country carry flood insurance, even though an estimated 32% of flood damage happens outside designated high-risk flood zones.

Myth 2: I should insure my home for what I paid for it. Market value and rebuilding cost are different numbers, and only the second one belongs on your policy. Market value includes the land and the location premium, neither of which an insurer has to replace. Replacement cost is the cost of rebuilding with comparable materials and labor at today's prices, and it can run higher than market value.

Fact: Underinsuring can cost you even on partial losses. Under the 80% rule, insuring for less than 80% of replacement cost can reduce what your insurer pays, even on a partial loss. Review your dwelling limit regularly.

Myth 3: My policy covers all my belongings, whatever they are worth. Personal property coverage is usually set at 50% to 70% of the dwelling value, with lower sublimits on certain valuables. Theft coverage for jewelry, for example, is often capped at $1,500 or $2,000 under a standard policy. Valuable items need separate scheduling or a floater to be fully protected.

Myth 4: My landlord's insurance covers my stuff. A landlord's policy typically covers the building structure and the landlord's own liability, not a tenant's belongings. Renters need their own renters insurance for their property and their liability. Without it, you pay out of pocket after a theft, fire, or water damage to your possessions.

More home myths: maintenance, vacancy, and earth movement

Myth 5: Home insurance pays for maintenance and repairs. A homeowners policy is not a home warranty. It is designed to cover sudden and accidental damage, not gradual deterioration, neglect, or deferred maintenance. A roof that slowly decays, plumbing that seeps from lack of upkeep, and mold or pest damage are generally the homeowner's responsibility. Mold is usually excluded unless it grows directly from a covered event such as a burst pipe, and even then remediation limits may apply.

Fact: Neglect can shrink a valid claim. If wind damages your roof and delayed repairs let water in, the insurer may limit or deny the water damage claim. Maintenance protects your coverage, not just your house.

Myth 6: Coverage stays the same if the house sits empty. Many policies contain vacancy clauses that limit or exclude coverage if a home is unoccupied for an extended period, often 60 consecutive days. Empty homes face higher risks of vandalism, theft, and water damage that goes unnoticed for weeks. Ask about a vacant property endorsement before a long absence.

Myth 7: Earthquakes and mudslides are covered. Most standard policies exclude earth movement, which includes earthquakes, mudslides, and sinkholes. Homeowners in seismic or landslide-prone areas may need a separate endorsement or a specialized earthquake policy. In California, coverage is available through the California Earthquake Authority.

Car insurance myths

Myth 8: A red car costs more to insure. Paint color is not a rating factor. Insurers price the year, make, model, body type, engine size, and age of the car, plus its drivers, and many never ask about color. The myth likely survives because red is associated with sports cars, which cost more for their power and repair costs, not their paint.

Myth 9: My auto policy covers theft, vandalism, and hail damage. Not unless you carry comprehensive coverage. A bare-bones policy usually carries only liability coverage, which pays for damage you cause to others. Theft, vandalism, fire, and hail damage to your own car need comprehensive coverage, and crash damage to your own car needs collision coverage. Reconsider both when their combined cost exceeds 10% of your vehicle's value.

Life insurance myths

Myth 10: Life insurance through work is enough, and buying my own is too expensive. Two errors in one sentence. Group life insurance through an employer is typically only one or two times your salary, against a common planning benchmark of around ten times, and it usually ends when you leave the job. Cost is widely overestimated: more than half of Americans overestimate term life costs by three times, according to a 2020 industry study. Term coverage for a young, healthy buyer can be surprisingly affordable, and buying early locks in lower rates.

How to check what you actually have

Pull out your policy and check three sections: the declarations page, the insuring agreement, and the exclusions. Confirm your dwelling limit reflects rebuilding cost, check the sublimits on valuables, confirm whether flood or earthquake coverage is missing, verify your auto coverage, and add up your life coverage from all sources. Review everything once a year, and keep a photo inventory of your belongings.