What Affects Your Insurance Premiums (and What You Can Change)
Your premium is a prediction about how likely you are to file a claim. Some inputs are fixed, but several of the biggest ones — driving record, credit, coverage choices, and shopping around — are within your control.
Every premium is a prediction. An insurer looks at dozens of signals about you, your property, and your past behavior, and sets a price based on how likely you are to file a claim and how expensive that claim would be. Some of those signals you cannot change. Several of the biggest ones you can — just not overnight.
Your history follows you — for years
Nothing shapes an auto premium like your driving record. In NerdWallet's November 2026 analysis, a driver with a clean record and good credit paid a national median of $2,357 a year for full coverage. One at-fault accident pushed that to $3,514, about 49% higher. A single speeding ticket raised it to $3,022, about 28% higher. A recent DUI took it to $4,424, about 88% higher. Violations and accidents generally stay on your record for three to five years.
Home insurance works the same way. A single recent claim raises homeowners premiums by 9% on average, and insurers pay particular attention to claim types like water damage, dog bites, and theft. That is one reason to think twice before filing a claim for damage barely above your deductible: the payout today can cost you more in premiums over the next few years than the claim was worth.
Credit: the factor most people underestimate
In most states, insurers use a credit-based insurance score — built from the same ingredients as a regular credit score, such as on-time payments and delinquencies, but weighted differently — to help set rates. Drivers with poor credit pay a median of $3,939 a year for full coverage, about 67% more than drivers with good credit. Homeowners with poor credit face average rates of $4,288 a year, a 72% increase over those with good credit.
Insurers point to data linking poor credit with more frequent claims. Whatever you think of the fairness of that, paying bills on time and keeping balances down is one of the highest-leverage things you can do for every insurance bill you pay. A few states disagree with the practice entirely — California, Hawaii, and Massachusetts do not allow insurers to use credit when setting car insurance rates.
Age, location, and what you own
Age matters most at the extremes. A 20-year-old with good credit and a clean record pays a median of $4,712 a year for full coverage — double the $2,357 median for a 35-year-old. Rates generally fall as you age past your twenties, bottoming out around age 60 at $2,024.
Where you live can matter just as much. Wyoming's average full coverage rate is $1,148 a year; Louisiana's is $4,290. State regulations, theft rates, traffic density, weather exposure, and repair costs all feed into the local price. What you insure matters too: sports cars, luxury cars with expensive parts, electric vehicles with costly batteries, and models that are stolen often all cost more to cover. For homes, a house built in 2025 costs 75% less to insure on average than one built more than 40 years ago, largely because newer homes use modern materials that cost less to replace.
The choices you make at purchase time
Coverage level is the most direct lever you control. Minimum coverage costs a national median of $650 a year versus $2,357 for full coverage, because minimum policies generally cover only liability, while full coverage adds collision and comprehensive protection for your own vehicle. But cheaper is not always wiser: if you have a loan or lease, you may be required to carry collision and comprehensive coverage.
For homeowners, the dwelling coverage limit — the amount that pays to rebuild after a covered loss — drives the price directly. A policy with a $200,000 dwelling limit costs an average of $1,478 a year, 69% cheaper than double that coverage, while an $800,000 limit costs roughly 44% more than a $400,000 one.
What you can actually change
Some factors are fixed — your age, your ZIP code, the year your house was built. But the list of levers you can pull is longer than most people realize:
1. Shop around, every year. Each insurer weights the same factors differently: one company might charge 10% more for poor credit while another charges 40%. Average full coverage rates range from $1,587 to $4,047 a year across large insurers for the same driver profile. Re-shop at renewal, after major life events, and in the month after the third and fifth anniversaries of an accident or violation.
2. Bundle home and auto. Buying both from one insurer saves 18% on average, according to NerdWallet's analysis of rates from four large carriers.
3. Protect your credit. On-time payments and low balances help your insurance score as well as your credit score, in every state that allows credit-based pricing.
4. Keep coverage continuous. A lapse in coverage marks you as riskier and raises rates, so avoid gaps even between policies.
5. Ask about discounts. Good-driver, claim-free, safety-feature, and multi-policy discounts vary widely by company, and some are only applied if you ask.
It also helps to know what is not your fault. Auto rates rose 32% over three years and home rates 24%, driven by inflation in repair and rebuilding costs, more frequent natural disasters, and rising reinsurance prices — the insurance that insurers themselves buy. When your renewal jumps despite a clean record, that broader market is usually the reason.